Why Was Julian Alvarez's Penalty Disallowed

Updated · 5 min read

Penalty kicks are among the most regulated moments in professional football. While fans often focus on the goalkeeper's positioning or encroachment by defenders, technical errors by the kicker are surprisingly frequent. These infractions, such as a double touch or an illegal feint, trigger an immediate whistle. Referees must enforce these rules strictly, as the advantage gained from an extra touch fundamentally alters the fairness of the spot kick.

Quick facts

FeatureRule Status
Double TouchProhibited
Kicker MovementForward only
Restart MethodIndirect free kick
VAR ReviewMandatory for goals

What are the specific rules governing penalty kicks in professional football?

The Laws of the Game dictate that a penalty kick must be taken from the penalty mark, with all other players positioned outside the penalty area and at least 9.15 meters from the mark until the ball is in play.

  • Ball placement: The sphere must be stationary on the penalty mark before the referee signals for the kick.
  • Kicker identity: The player taking the kick must be clearly identified to the referee before the attempt.
  • Goal scoring: A goal may be scored directly from a penalty kick, provided no other infractions occur.
  • Time extension: A penalty kick awarded at the end of a half must be completed, even if time expires.

How does the video assistant referee (VAR) system determine if a penalty should be overturned?

Yes, VAR uses high-frame-rate cameras to verify technical compliance with the Laws of the Game. If the system detects a double touch or encroachment, the referee is directed to the pitch-side monitor to review the footage, ensuring the final decision is based on a clear and obvious factual error.

Did player encroachment play a role in the officiating decision?

Encroachment occurs when a teammate or opponent enters the penalty area or the arc before the ball is kicked, potentially influencing the outcome of the play. If an attacking player encroaches and the ball enters the net, the goal is disallowed and the kick is retaken. For example, if a teammate of the kicker crosses the line early, the referee must intervene regardless of whether that player touches the ball.

A nuance exists when the ball rebounds off the post or goalkeeper. If a player encroaches but the ball is cleared by the defense, the referee might allow play to continue if the action did not impact the defensive clearance. However, if the encroaching player gains an advantage, the referee must penalize the infraction, often resulting in an indirect free kick for the defending side.

How do match officials interpret player movement before the ball is struck?

Officials monitor the kicker's approach to make sure the movement is continuous and does not involve illegal feinting once the run-up has concluded.

  • Feinting: Players are permitted to feint during the run-up, but stopping completely once at the ball is a cautionable offense for unsporting behavior.
  • Continuous motion: The kicker must maintain a fluid forward momentum toward the ball to prevent unfair deception of the goalkeeper.
  • Goalkeeper positioning: The keeper must have at least part of one foot touching or in line with the goal line when the ball is struck.
  • Referee signal: The kick cannot proceed until the official has verified that both teams are in their required positions.

What is the protocol for restarting play after a penalty is disallowed?

The match restarts with an indirect free kick awarded to the opposing team at the spot where the second touch occurred. This restart is mandatory under Law 14, which explicitly forbids the kicker from touching the ball a second time before it has made contact with another player.

Have there been historical precedents for disallowing penalties due to technical infractions?

Yes, penalties have been disallowed for technical infractions throughout the history of professional football, such as when players have attempted to pass the ball forward to a teammate instead of shooting. Many people assume that a double touch during a penalty is a rare, accidental occurrence, but it is often a deliberate, albeit illegal, tactical maneuver intended to confuse the goalkeeper. Officials are trained to watch the kicker's feet specifically for this reason, as the speed of modern play makes such subtle infractions difficult to detect without the aid of video technology.

How does the referee communicate the rationale for a disallowed penalty to the players and spectators?

Referees communicate the decision by signaling the specific infraction, such as pointing to the ground to indicate a double touch or raising an arm to signal the indirect free kick. In high-level matches, the official often uses a hand gesture to indicate that a VAR review has taken place, followed by a clear explanation to the team captains. For instance, after a disallowed penalty, the referee will point toward the spot of the infraction to clarify why the restart is occurring there rather than at the center circle.

A notable exception occurs when the referee is not required to provide a verbal explanation to the entire stadium, as the visual signals are intended to be self-explanatory. While players may protest, the referee's decision remains final once the restart signal is given, and further argument can lead to dissent-related cautions.

What people often get wrong

  • Blaming the referee's vision. People often assume the official missed the call, but VAR technology now captures micro-movements that occur in milliseconds.
  • Confusing a slip with a touch. A player slipping is legal, but if that slip causes the ball to strike the standing foot, it becomes a violation.
  • Ignoring the restart rule. Many spectators expect a retake, but a double touch results in an indirect free kick for the defending team.

Understanding Technical Infractions in Penalties

Focus on the sequence of contact rather than the outcome of the strike when evaluating penalty decisions. Familiarizing yourself with the specific restart protocols helps clarify why certain goals are overturned despite the ball clearly entering the net.